Owl wrote: there is NOT a breath's worth of difference between 99% of the Republicans in office and 100% of the democrats.
And I love you man but I have to disagree. It is easy to hip-shoot and call everyone a RINO but that is intellectual laziness. The republicans have their flaws but in the shadow of the democrats, it is like a penny shop-lifter standing next to Bernie Madoff.
We are a two party world, always. It is because we are a binary world world. All questions eventually distill down to "Yes" or "No". Put 50 people in a room and throw in volatile argument and eventually you will have two sides. As long as you are arguing about an idea, it will be Y and N. If you are arguing about people, the choices are as many as participants. But we are not a banana republic(yet) and are still a nation of laws and rule of law. Laws are ideas. From a moral perspective, I see the world in Black and White. Moral grayness is a failing.
I am not a Republican Lemming though I can hardly imagine myself ever voting Democrat in a national election. I think our only hope is to strongly influence the GOP and push it to the right. Don't let their silence frighten you. It is the same strategy that they used in 1994, leading up to the take-over. They laid low in hopes of not waking up the liberal base on the other side. The results was a historical landslide. We will win big in November. The question what we do with the win. I am hoping that the GOP learned from the post '94 fiasco and does not repeat the same mistakes, as bad.
Another aspect is geography. Rudy Giuliani would be considered a liberal down here. He is pro-choice and has other liberal social views. But he did not run for mayor of Buford, GA. He was the mayor of NY City and the best one in the history of that city. Before Rudy, you would not be on the streets of NY after dark. That has changed. The same goes with Brown in Mass. Change can only happen so fast in these places and you cannot get a Ray McBerry elected in NY City. So you take as much as you can and keep pushing the envelop. I am not talking about compromising principles. I am talking about strategy!
The GOP did a stellar fight against health care. Not one vote with an (r) went to the bill! How much more can you ask for!
The danger of replacing an old party with a new one is much as a ConCon. What you end up may be worse than what you left. Since you are opening up the party to numerous power struggles, anything goes. We can run around with 25 little parties, each with their own charismatic conservative under the banner of "Constitutionalists Christians", "Christian Constitutionalists", "Constitutionalists Popular Party" , etc., etc. while the liberals walk away with the elections.
I want a conservative Republican party that has the courage to reverse the damage done by the liberals and put safe guards in place to prevent it from happening again.